Ok, I finally broke down and purchased a copy of Meyer's Twilight. First, I should say that I read it quickly over one weekend. This illustrates that it is entertaining enough. It's a quick read, and although there wasn't all that much suspense, I felt like I wanted to keep reading. In spite of all that, I have to say that I don't get what all the hype is about. A couple of my students informed me that it's really "deep" and "profound," unlike much YA fiction that simply deals with high school boy-girl relationships. But that's just not the case. I mean, Twilight seemed to me like more of the same--the melodramatic, angst filled, fraught 17-year-old relationship, with a vampire thrown into the mix. But the vampire angle felt almost arbitrary (should I say "random"?). But seriously, I found the book troubling in ways that have nothing to do with vampires. What I think bothered me most is that the book, of course, is set up such that we, the readers, want Bella and Edward to be together. And you know--this is fine, I guess. Whatever. I mean, it's like Harlequin for teens, but fine. But Edward is so controlling of Bella. And he really doesn't allow her to assert her opinions. And when he wants something that she doesn't, he just kinda forces her. I am NOT referring to sex (although the book was more sexually suggestive than I expected). It's like Edward wants to go for a walk; Bella says no; he just throws her over his shoulder and carries her off. And Bella, who is also our narrator, doesn't seem to see that this is a problem. Nor does our author seem to see it. And that's kinda what bothers me. I don't expect Bella to be especially perceptive or mature. She is, after all, 17. But the writing seems to lack depth. Meyer doesn't encourage us to perceive the world with more maturity than Bella does. And this is troubling, in part, but it mostly marks the work as superficial and not terribly literary. There's just not a lot of substance there.
I will spare you any sort of rant about the film. I've not seen it and probably won't. I have nothing against the film, per se. I do, however, wonder about the mothers who allow their 10 year olds to mob the poor actor who plays Edward, as they scratch their necks in hopes of drawing blood. Of course, this is no reflection on the film or the actor, but it's just kinda creepy.
a president, a King
13 years ago




